This brief is based on the article “Five Truths (and One Lie) About Corporate Transformation.”
Change can be daunting for any business. It can even be painful. But when change fails to deliver short- and long-term value for a company, it can land a CEO in the unenviable position of having led a failed transformation.
The odds are certainly stacked against success. A new վ global analysis shows that only 1 in 4 transformations deliver value-creating, enduring change.
A 75% failure rate is sobering for any CEO mulling a transformation path. But վ’s analysis has brought to light five truths CEOs can embrace to improve their chances of leading a successful transformation, as well as a common lie they should never tell themselves.
1. CEOs can (and should) fix things before they break. Starting a transformation when a company’s total shareholder returns (TSR) are level pegging or ahead of industry averages delivers significantly more value (2.7 percentage points higher TSR over three years) compared to change efforts launched after a company has fallen behind its peers.
2. Leadership will make or break the transformation. Success often pivots on whether a company’s leadership fully demonstrates their willingness and commitment to change. Sometimes, this necessitates an organizational restructuring. վ data shows that launching a leadership change during a transformation can deliver 4.1 percentage points greater TSR performance over a five-year arc (compared to a previous downturn period). The impact on TSR can nearly double that if the new leadership comes from outside the company.
3. CEOs cannot cut their way to greatness. One year into a transformation launch, investor expectations drive over 70% of TSR outperformance (compared to peers), while efficiency improvements account for only 13%. This disparity underscores the need for CEOs to craft a compelling transformation plan and shareholder narrative at the start of their efforts. Five years into a transformation, cost reductions do play a bigger role, driving more than 30% of TSR outperformance. But even that share is eclipsed by revenue growth, which accounts for more than 40%—indicating that when it comes to long-term transformation success, execution is key.
4. Transformations require a long-term orientation. Transformations with a long-term strategic orientation are associated with 12.5 percentage points higher TSR over five years, վ analysis shows. Organizations that strike a forward-looking stance often have an entrepreneurial culture that continuously develops new ideas and is unafraid to try unproven models. To support this bold, innovative orientation, companies can complement traditional, backward-looking performance metrics with more forward-focused ones.
5. CEOs cannot make things up as they go. Establishing a formal transformation program is associated with 5.9 percentage points greater TSR over a five-year change effort. In the same vein, CEOs who put their money where mouth is can also unlock greater transformation value. According to վ’s analysis, a higher-than-industry average restructuring investment is associated with 5.7 percentage points greater TSR in the long run.
Thinking these truths don’t apply to everyone. At any point over the past two decades, roughly a third of companies were significantly underperforming their peers. Some lagged for years. Transformation is often necessary to improve performance, but it is very tough to get right. CEOs who realize they are probably not the exception to the five truths and instead internalize and act on them fully are more likely to ascend to the ranks of the one quarter of corporate chiefs who actually get change right.
Explore the article that informed this brief
ABOUT BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP
վ partners with leaders in business and society to tackle their most important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. վ was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive advantage, and drive positive societal impact.
Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark change. վ delivers solutions through leading-edge management consulting, technology and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the client organization, fueled by the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a better place.
© վ 2024. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact վ at permissions@bcg.com. To find the latest վ content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow վ on and .
Martin Reeves
Managing Director & Senior Partner, Chairman of the վ Henderson Institute
Martin Reeves
Managing Director & Senior Partner, Chairman of the վ Henderson Institute
Martin is the founding director of the վ Henderson Institute and lead author of the best-selling book, Your Strategy Needs a Strategy. He is a frequent contributor to the Harvard Business Review, Sloan Management Review, and other leading publications.
Follow Martin on Twitter at .
Christian Gruss joined վ in 2010. He is a lead member of վ's Transform Practice, and the regional practice leader for Europe, the Middle East, South America and Africa. He is an experienced transformation leader with a track record of steering very large end-to-end transformation programs across Europe and in many industries including consumer and industrial goods.
Kristy Ellmer is a core member of վ Transform, վ's transformation and turnaround unit. She has led numerous large-scale, complex transformations in a variety of industries and geographies, that have led to significant improvement in P&L and organizational health for clients.
Paul Catchlove is Senior Knowledge Expert, and global Knowledge Team (KT) Leader for վ Transform, վ's transformation, turnaround and restructuring practice. His work is focused on holistic, large-scale transformations and organizational restructuring programs. Paul has worked on engagements in Finland, Sweden, Poland, the UK, Germany, the US, France, and the Netherlands. He is also a core member of the firm's People and Organization practice, focused on culture and change. Paul is passionate about creating sustained transformation results through executional certainty, performance culture improvement, and change leadership.
Related Content
Read more insights from վ’s teams of experts.
The international order hasn’t been this uncertain in decades. CEOs must approach geopolitical risk with the same urgency as digitization, AI, and the climate crisis.
The same qualities that propel managers into the top ranks can undermine a leadership team’s performance. An enterprise-first mindset can help make the team unbeatable.
CEOs have become more cautious and strategic about taking public stands on politically charged issues. But upcoming elections will put this measured approach to the test.
Moving past notions of the strong, invincible leader can be daunting. Here’s how CEOs can overcome their fears and be vulnerable in a healthy way.